After a refreshing hibernation,
the pull of the road begins to re-assert itself: the destination for our Spring 2009
trip is settled on Sardinia and Corsica. As usual, early Spring travel brings its own additional
challenges: finding campsites open for the drive down through France and
Italy, and the uncertainty of weather conditions crossing the Alps by our
favoured Fréjus Tunnel route. There is a bewildering choice of ferry crossings to
Sardinia from Italy,
depending on how far you want to brave the hazards of the Italian autostrada.
One thing they all have in common: they are expensive, but we
have opted for the Livorno to Olbia route using Moby Lines Ferries. As
always, we recommend
www.viamare.com for details of Mediterranean ferry routes.
What attracts us to explore these
two Mediterranean islands is the fact that, although now provinces
of the Italian (Sardinia) and French (Corsica) states,
both islands manage to retain their unique cultures which owe much
to their fascinating histories. As always in our Prologue we give a
foretaste of the topographical, cultural and historical backgrounds
of our two host islands.
SARDINIA:
GEOGRAPHY and CULTURE:
set 200 kms from both the Italian mainland and North African coast,
Sardinia is the Mediterranean's 2nd largest island after Sicily,
with a population of 1.6 million. Although on the sidelines of
mainstream Mediterranean historical events, the island's
strategic
position on trade routes meant that it has rarely been free of
foreign intervention which has left a rich archaeological, artistic
and cultural legacy. The official Sardinian flag shows
four blindfolded Moorish heads, similar to the Corsican flag; its
origins are thought to represent captured North African pirates
whose raids plagued the island for centuries, hence its name The
Four Moors (Quattro Mori).
Most of Sardinia is a
mountainous plateau gradually sloping to the sea, covered with Holm
and cork oaks;
the highest
point, Punta La Marmora, rises to 1,834m (6,016 feet). The lower rocky coastal terrain
is like
Corsica covered by an impenetrable scrub (macchia
in Italian) of characteristic aromatic shrubs such as
myrtle, arbutus, mastic, and lentisk, blossoming in Spring with brightly coloured cistus
flowers.
Despite centuries of occupation, finally becoming part of the kingdom of Italy in 1861,
Sardinia has retained an untamed and fiercely independent cultural
identity. Ancient traditions, now deeply rooted in
Catholicism but
showing traces of far older pre-Christian religious inheritance, can
be seen in the many festivals often based on the close relationship
between islanders and their natural environment. Sardinia's isolated position has
produced a dialect so distinct as to constitute an almost separate
language; although a Romance language of Latin origin, Sard has been
influenced by Catalan and Spanish, with an obscure Pre-Roman
element, including Phoenician, Etruscan, and Near Eastern languages.
While it has been largely supplanted by Italian for official
purposes, Sard is still widely spoken in inland rural parts and,
stemming from a long history of oral tradition, is used in folk songs and poetry. Music and dancing feature strongly in
Sardinian culture: the tradition of cantu a chiterra (guitar
songs) has its origins in town squares, with artists competing
against one another. Sardinia is home also to one of the oldest
forms of vocal polyphony, known as cantu a tenore, recorded
by the now world-famous traditional four-part polyphonic singing
group, the Tenores di Bitti from the town of Bitti in
the central mountainous region.
Early history: the
origin of the indigenous Sards is unknown, but the earliest traces
of human settlement go back beyond 6,000 BC when a hunting and
pastoral society occupied villages on the island, later trading in
flint, obsidian and ceramics with neighbouring Mediterranean
islands. The
succeeding Nuraghic Culture, which flourished on Sardinia from the
mid-third millennium BC and reached its apogee in the eighth century
BC, has left imposing stone-built remains of their
tower-fortifications around the island. Constructed like Greek
tholos tombs, these towers protected elaborate settlement-complexes such as
those at Su Nuraxi. Phoenicians from the eastern Mediterranean
established peaceful trading colonies on Sardinia from around 900
BC,
attracted here by the island's mineral resources. They were
supplanted by the more aggressive Carthaginians from near Tunis who
incorporated the island into their expanding empire, destroying or
assimilating the Nuraghic Culture and Phoenicians. The emerging
power of Rome brought inevitable clash with Carthage, whose empire
was finally destroyed by the Romans in 146 BC. Under Roman rule,
Sardinia was bled of its agricultural and mineral resources, while
native Sards continued a semi-autonomous existence in the island's
interior. As well as substantial remains of Roman occupation, Rome's
lasting legacy to Sardinia was the marked Latin elements still to be
heard in the Sard dialect today.
Medieval Sardinia: with
the Roman Empire's collapse in the 5th century AD, Sardinia shared
the fate of other former Roman territories becoming increasingly
vulnerable to plundering raids from barbarian Vandals, and later
becoming a western outpost of the Byzantine Empire. The island
increasingly became the preserve of local aristocratic powerful
families who ruled Sardinia's four
territorial divisions, the Giudicati (see left) as independent
principalities. Faced with raids on Sardinia by the expanding Moorish empires from North Africa
and Spain, the papacy encouraged the mercantile republics of Pisa
and Genoa to intervene and from 1000 AD, Sardinia enjoyed
increasingly open trading, political and artistic links with
mainland Italy as seen in the legacy of Romanesque churches of that
period. By lending support in the various conflicts between the
Giudicati, the rival cities of Pisa
and Genoa took an increasingly active role in Sardinian affairs.
During the 14th century, the Spanish kingdom of Aragon made claims
on Sardinia; the ensuing struggle between Aragon and the
aristocratic Giudicati for command of the island lasted for more
than a century. The island's cause was championed by Eleanor of
Arborea (see right) who granted Sardinia its first written code of laws (Carta
de Logu) and is still revered today for stemming the Aragonese advance.
Her rule marked the final glorious chapter of Sardinian
independence, but after her death in 1404, the Aragonese finally
controlled all of Sardinia, a rule which lasted for three centuries.
Compared with the preceding turmoil, this was an unusually peaceful
period but still with no improvements in the lot of the
Sardinian people: there were few attempts to develop or improve infrastructure,
and Sardinia was parcelled up between Aragonese feudal
nobles and ruled by viceroys indifferent to the island's welfare.
The island was afflicted by plague, famine and malaria, and the
period of Spanish rule was a barren one for Sardinia which was
relegated to the status of exploited and deprived backwater.
Kingdom of Sardinia, 19th
Century unification with Italy,
and the 20th century: as Spanish power declined in the
early years of the 18th century, events elsewhere in Europe impinged
on Sardinia: negotiations following the War of Spanish
Succession
ceded the island first to Habsburg Austria then in 1718 to the Piedmontese
Duchy of Savoy. Savoyard rule of the Kingdom of Sardinia brought
some reconstruction, but serious economic and social crisis led to increasing unrest and resurgence of clan
warfare, kidnappings and banditry in the rural interior. The
deep-rooted cause of Sard hostility was the new ruling elite's
intransigence and failure to abolish the feudal system. In the
turmoil following the 1789 French Revolution, France attempted
unsuccessfully to conquer Sardinia, but by 1795 the island was
overwhelmed by revolution against Savoy rule and its feudal privileges; the
leader of Sardinia's revolutionary demands for constitutional reform, Giovanni Angioy, is still today
regarded as the greatest Sardinian patriot and national hero. The
most noteworthy Savoyard 19th century ruler of Sardinia was Carlo
Felice (1821~31) who modernised the island's infrastructure,
building the main SS131 highway which runs the length of the island
and still bears his name.
With
the Unification of Italy in 1861, Sardinia became
part of the Kingdom of Italy with Vittorio Emanuele
as the new nation's first King. The island had
earlier provided a base from which Garibaldi and his
Thousand Redshirts embarked on the military
campaigns leading to Risorgimento
(struggle for
nationhood). Italian unification brought new
problems for
Sardinia: adjusting to its role in a modern
nation-state became the overriding theme of the next
century. Despite improvements in infrastructure and
industrialisation, Sardinia remained an exploited
backwater: natural resources were plundered and
agriculture suffered leading to soaring unemployment
which further fuelled rural banditry. By the end of
the 19th century, voting rights were enjoyed by less
than 5% of Sardinia's population leaving the
majority of islanders unrepresented. Despite this,
Sardinian troops of the Brigata Sassari fought with
distinction in WW1, albeit with heavy losses.
Ironically, Sardinia had to wait for a ruthless,
centralising Fascist dictatorship before real change
began to be felt: Mussolini, who came to power in
1922, saw the backward island as fertile ground for
his socio-economic experiments, particularly in the
pursuit of Italian self-sufficiency. The island's
rivers were dammed to provide irrigation and power,
and the mining industry was developed to exploit mineral
resources; land reclamation, agricultural colonies
and foundation of new towns led to increased
production. The island suffered badly from allied
bombing in WW2, but to offset the post-war period of
Sardinia's feeling of still being a second class
member of the Italian state, subject to remote
bureaucracy and irrelevant legislation, the island
like Sicily was granted the status of autonomous
regione with direct legislative control over
transport, tourism, police, industry and
agriculture. Foreign aid enabled the elimination
of the age-old scourge of malaria; coastal
marshlands were reclaimed making possible the
development of agriculture, market gardens and
orchards.
Sardinia today: the late 20th century successful efforts belatedly to drag Sardinia out from its
peripheral third world status
can be felt today: in the towns at least, life is
indistinguishable from that of mainland Italy. Much of the island's
present day climate
results from two
1960s developments: a
programme of petro-chemical industrialisation, and development of the Costa Smeralda
as an luxury holiday resort leading to the opening up of
an increased tourist industry. Both have brought a
degree of affluence to a substantial part of the
population. The price of this tourist economy has been
unrestrained development and unregulated degradation of
parts of the island's natural environment in pursuit of
short-tern profit for the few. But alongside this
unwelcome aspect of tourist development, there is a new
appreciation of traditional culture, dialect, folklore
and music, and a corresponding pride in Sard identity.
Despite the high levels of unemployment and resentment
of Italian bureaucracy, there is general satisfaction
with Sardinia's place within Italy and the EU;
campaigning by the Partito Sardo d'Azione for Sardinia's
independence is too marginal to exert significant
influence. Sardinia's future is best symbolised by
Renato Soru, the Sardinian-born head of the internet service provider Tiscali, President of the Regione di Sardegna,
and head of the Centre-Left coalition
with a controversial programme to reinvigorate the
island's economy with external investment.
GEOGRAPHY and CULTURE:
called by the ancient Greeks Kalliste (most beautiful),
Corsica lies 190 miles south of Marseille and just 50 miles from
the Tuscan coast. At just 183 kms in length and 85 kms in width, the
island is half the size of Wales, one third the area of Sardinia,
and is the
most
mountainous of Mediterranean islands; its highest point, Monte Cinto,
at 2,706m (8,877 feet) is second only to Etna in height. The
highlands are forested with oak, chestnut and pines, and like
Sardinia, the lower slopes are covered with dense, spiny scrubland,
maquis, which over the centuries has provided a hideout for
bandits and fugitives and which gave its name to WW2 resistance fighters,
maquisards.
The French départments of Corse du Sud and Haute Corse together
have some 260,000 inhabitants (and an estimated 30,000 wild boar!)
with a half million more Corsicans now living in metropolitan France.
Like
its neighbour Sardinia, Corsica's abundant natural
resources and its strategic position on the
Mediterranean seaways have across history attracted
successive invaders.
Few however have been able to subdue the islanders' fiercely independent and
rebellious spirit. Two
hundred years of French rule have had limited tangible
impact on Corsicans whose indigenous language, Corsu,
shows close affinity with
medieval Tuscan from its Romance origins; 'Good Morning, how are you?'
in Corsican is 'Bonghjurnu, Cumu hè?' Compare
this with Italian. Unlike
most European minority languages however, Corsu is spoken by over 80% of the island's native population. The Corsican flag, the Bandera Testa di Moru,
showing the emblem of a Moor's Head with white
bandanna,
was adopted by 18th century nationalists in their
struggle for independence and originates from
past rule by the Kings of Aragon.
Having struggled for centuries to preserve their
language and culture, Corsicans cling doggedly to their
traditions. While their modern tourist economy
and reliance on EU subsidies draws them closer into the
European mainstream, interest in traditional Corsican
music flourishes, particularly the haunting sound of
polyphonic singing such as the hymn to the island's
patroness Virgin Mary Diu vi salvi
Regina (now playing). The Catholic year in Corsica is filled with
festivals and rituals, some of which pre-date
Christianity in origin. But alongside this, a darker
side of Corsican traditional life coexists: mysterious religious brotherhoods, belief in the occult
and primitive magic, second sight, the 'evil eye' and
exorcism; 19th century blood feuds and murders prompted
by offended family honour and clan rivalries have
bequeathed us the word vendetta. Bombings and
shootings motivated by violent opposition to French rule
claimed 100s of lives during the 1980s and 90s; but the
nationalist posturing of the FLNC (Front de la
Libération Nationale de la Corse) separatist movement
has more recently been discredited by links with
Mafia racketeers, organised crime, extortion and
turf-war killings. Today, despite the ubiquitous
graffiti and vandalised road signs, such extremism
enjoys little popular support.
Early history: with
its strategic setting on Mediterranean trade routes and
the commercial appeal of its sheltered harbours, invasion,
occupation and resistance have been recurring themes
throughout Corsica's turbulent history. The island was
originally settled by Neolithic hunter-gatherers as
early as 7,000 BC; these indigenous peoples living in
rock shelters were supplanted by further
waves of
settlers who brought agricultural skills, lived in
villages and developed ceramics, weaving and eventually
copper-working. Around 3,000 BC, subsequent migrants
brought megalithic building skills and buried their dead
in dolmens protected by alignments of standing stones; more distinctly,
they erected menhirs
in the form of anthropomorphic statues to honour their
dead leaders. From 1,500 BC, these peaceful agricultural
megalith-builders were driven north into the interior
by new Bronze Age aggressors armed with metal weapons
depicted on the sword-bearing menhirs at Filitosa. This
has been called the Torréen culture after the
corbelled towers (torres, similar to the
Sardinian Nuraghi) guarding their fortified settlements
(casteddu), whose remains are still to be seen
around Corsica. Bronze weapons, ceramic artefacts and
tholos-like tower-building skills suggest the
Torréens had contact with Mycenaean Greece and
other Mediterranean civilisations.
Successive invaders - 565 BC~500 AD:
over the next millennium, Corsica's history mirrored
that of neighbouring Sardinia, with successivewaves of colonists or invaders
occupying the island and resisted by native Corsicans. In 565 BC Greeks
from Phocaea in Asia Minor founded the trading colony of Alalia, Corsica's
first urban settlement (modern Aléria
on the east coast), introducing the Mediterranean
staples of wheat, vine and olives. Within 30 years
however, they were driven out by Etruscan forces and went on to found Marseille. In turn the Carthaginians
added Corsica to their growing empire in 280 BC, but
were later defeated by the Romans during the Punic Wars
which eventually destroyed Carthage in 146 BC. Unlike
previous invaders who were content to occupy coastal
settlements leaving the inaccessible interior to
indigenous islanders, the Romans over time conquered the
whole island, crushing or enslaving the rebellious
population. Corsica was exploited for its agricultural
produce; the native population who survived learnt to
speak Latin and were later Christianised. And so matters
remained until the Roman empire imploded in the late 5th
century AD.
Vandals, Byzantines, Lombards, Moors, and Genoans - 500~1729 AD:
reflecting the fate of Sardinia,
hard times followed the Romans as successive
waves of seaborne invaders drove the native Corsicans
into the interior. The Vandals true to their
image wrought havoc destroying Alalia
after a millennium of civilisation. They in turn were
helped on their way in 534 AD by Byzantine Greeks, to be
succeeded in 725 AD by barbarous Lombards who soon
overran Italy. After the Franks under Pepin had
defeated the Lombards in 754 AD, Corsica was later
gifted by his son Charlemagne to papal control. For the
next 2 centuries, Corsica was harassed by marauding
Moorish pirates. During these Dark Ages, local
chieftains struggled to gain control, until the Pope
officially handed Corsica to the Republic of Pisa to
govern, bringing a degree of peace unknown since the
Romans' departure. Increasingly however, Corsica became
a pawn in the struggle between the competing trading
empires of Pisa and Genoa, until the Genoans finally
gained full control of the island in 1284. They ruled
for the next 450 years despite lengthy attempts to wrest
control from them by the Kingdom of Aragon, continued
rebellious opposition from native Corsican noble
families (signori), and the onslaught of malaria
and famine.
Corsican Wars of Independence - 1729~1768: during
the later years of Genoese rule, resentment of Genoa's
trade monopolies, high taxation and exclusion from real
power spilled over. Influential bourgeois families who
had benefitted from the boom in agriculture formed an
articulate
and ambitious leadership for a Corsican society growing in
political maturity and aspirations. Matters came to a
head in 1729 when discontent exploded into armed
rebellion. The uprising spread quickly and was formalised in 1731 when the popular assembly declared
national independence: Corsica gained the first
constitution of any modern parliamentary democracy 50
years before the USA, and Diu vi salvi
Regina, the hymn to the Virgin was adopted as
national anthem. As with the American War of
Independence, the European powers intervened with an eye
to strategic advantage: first Austrian then French
troops backed the weakened Genoese, and an English fleet
supported the Corsican patriots led by their military
commander Gian'Pietru Gaffori (see left). Gaffori was assassinated in 1753, and the Corsicans
summoned Pascal Paoli, son of the exiled Corsican
leader, to take over the rebellion. Paoli (see right)
was elected leader of the Corsican nation: one of the
most remarkable politicians of the Enlightenment and well-versed in constitutional theory, he introduced a
democratic constitution based on the principles of
sovereignty of the people and separation of powers, with
wide suffrage and representative government. He founded
the island's first University, set up a printing press
and mint, and even managed to reduce vendetta killings
through the death penalty. But events were overtaking
the Corsicans: the Genoese finally ceded their claim to
Corsica under the 1768 Treaty of Versailles, selling the island to France.
Within a month, an invading French army inflicted a
decisive defeat on the Corsican rebels at the Battle of
Ponto-Nuovo: France became a French possession in May
1769, Paoli fled to England, and shortly after, a
Corsican noble woman Letizia Bonaparte gave birth to her
second son, Napoléon.
Napoléon
and Corsica - 1769~1796: although sporadic
resistance continued after Paoli's exile, Corsica was
assimilated into the French State. Napoléon's father,
Carlo Bonaparte, once a loyal Corsican and supporter of
Paoli, transferred
the family's loyalty to France
becoming ambassador to the French court, and along with
the sons of other Corsican nobles, Napoléon was awarded
a scholarship to a French military academy. Over the
next 20 years of rule by the French monarchy, demands
for independence subsided. With the French Revolution
promising liberty, equality and fraternity, Corsica
sought equal status and in 1789 became an integral part
of France. The ban on political exiles was lifted and
Paoli returned to Corsica the hero to be elected Council
President. Paris' republican extremism however caused him to break with France and in 1793, he again declared
Corsica's independence. The Bonaparte family packed
their bags for France, never to return. Paoli called on
help from England, and a British fleet was dispatched to
oust the remaining French forces; it was in this action
that the young Horatio Nelson lost his left eye. In
return, the British demanded joint-rule of Corsica and
Paoli was persuaded into exile again to London, this
time for good. He died in 1807 and his memorial can now
be seen in Westminster Abbey (see right). In 1796, Napoléon's
forces retook Corsica which has been incontrovertibly
French ever since. Napoléon never returned to the island
of his birth during his period of power.
Corsica in the 19th and 20th centuries: despite
attempts to develop the economy, education and communications during the 19th
century, Corsica remained a marginalised and largely neglected corner of the
state. The island's romantically idealised image masked a grim picture of
poverty, famine and malaria, and the lack of effective law enforcement and
justice left banditry, vendetta violence and murders unpunished. Economic
stagnation prompted widespread emigration; WW1 reduced Corsica's population even
further. In WW2 as German forces invaded France, 85,000 of Mussolini's troops
augmented by 10,000 Germans occupied Corsica, one soldier for every two Corsicans.
After 2,000 years experience of resisting occupation, Corsica soon had the most
effective partisan movement in France numbering some 12,000 combatants supplied
with arms and explosives by submarine. The name
Maquisards was given to the French underground as a whole, originating from
the dense scrub which had been a refuge of Corsican outlaws for centuries. After
the Italian surrender in 1943, German forces were evacuated to the Italian
mainland harried by the Corsican Resistance, and by October 1943, Corsica
became the first départment of Metropolitan France to be liberated. Allied forces stayed on to help restart
the island's economy by clearing malarial mosquitoes and enabling the
resettlement of coastal plains.
The French state and Corsican nationalist
extremism - le Problème
Corse: the revival of Corsican nationalism in the late 20th century
emerged in
response to the island's steady economic decline under French rule:
riacquistu - the 're-acquisition' of everything Corsican - covered language, music,
culture, but also sturdy political demands for Corsican autonomy. Alongside the rise
in tourism, successive French
governments' predominant response to Corsica's
economic woes was both neglect and visionless subsidies; emigration and
depopulation, and decline of agriculture left Corsica the poorest départment in
France. Against this background of insecurity and Paris' ineffectual economic
solutions, demands increased for greater nationalistic determination. With
Corsican history of resistance to oppression, and age-old
traditions of vendetta, clannish mistrust and mutual violence, it was no surprise when rival
nationalist parties resorted to bomb and bullet as much against one another as
against the French state. The 1970s~80s saw relentless increase in nationalistic violence
with bombings, assassinations, and recrimination killings, and the spread of extortion, protection-racketeering and armed robberies as the
means of fund raising by extremist groups. The FLNC (Front de la Libération
Nationale de la Corse) fragmented into rival splinter groups seemingly more
intent on mutual discrediting or destruction than pursuing long-term solutions
with the French state. During the 1990s, successive French governments' attempts
to achieve lasting solution by devolution of power were frustrated by political
scandals or continued violence. Crackdown on lawlessness and corruption filled
French prisons, while the image of the separatist groups was sullied by
revelations of links with organised crime.
Vast sums of state and EU development monies have
been poured into Corsica to develop the island's infrastructure, reduce
unemployment and promote a sustainable economy. The majority of islanders
benefit from such unprecedented subsidies, state employment, welfare
handouts and tax exemptions; separatism no longer enjoys the public support it
once did, yet despite all the initiatives, lasting political and economic
solution remains as distant as ever. With Corsica's historical legacy of
infighting and vendettas, violence continues as the
response to political differences with the French state, and the wealth of
billions of state and EU subsidies provides rich pickings for corruption,
extortion rackets and paramilitaries.
A referendum in 2003 by the then
Minister of the Interior Nicolas Sarkozy, offering Corsicans a far-reaching
package of devolutionary legislative powers and unified regional assembly, was
narrowly rejected. Nationalists responded to the no-vote by blowing up four more
holiday homes. Sarkozy, who succeeded Jacques Chirac in 2007 as President of the
French Republic, has been frustrated by the political disarray; he has continued
the process of devolution and promise of investment along with a hard line
against the separatists on grounds of extortion and organised crime rather than
terrorism. His policy of carrot and stick, and his personal interest in the
island, raises genuine expectations of success among honest Corsicans. The story
continues ....
So that's
the chequered and turbulent background story of Sardinia and Corsica so far.
There is so much more to learn and to understand than the superficially
misleading impressions formed by tourists sitting on Mediterranean beaches. We hope
our travels will give the opportunity of learning
more for ourselves about the two islands' distinctive identities, history and culture,
and understanding more about peoples' opinion on the controversial issue of
separatism and hopes for a politically and economically stable future. We set
off in March and as usual we shall be publishing
regular updates to our web site, with news and pictures
of our travels. Add the site to your Favourites and share our travels; we should welcome your companionship.